X Close

Yes
Print
All Projects [Home] — PublicationsMedia ReleasesEducation
A A A

November 16, 2011

In Brief:

 

  • The right to free association is widely understood to include an individual’s right not to associate with or belong to any particular organization.
  • In Canada, the freedom to associate is abridged when post-secondary students are forced to belong to student unions as a condition for pursuing higher education. In all 10 provinces, membership in student unions and paying union dues are mandatory.
  • Student Unions are not governments, do not provide public goods, and many of the goods that they do provide (such as dental insurance, additional medical benefits) could easily be provided by markets or voluntary student organizations that students could join and support financially if they so choose.
  • The exercise of individual rights and freedoms such as the freedom to associate should only be restricted if there is an urgent need to do so. None of the arguments that are used to justify compulsory student unionism meet this test.


Media Release - The Case for Voluntary Student Unionism

Winnipeg: The Frontier Centre for Public Policy today released The Case for Voluntary Student Unionism.  This backgrounder describes the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms’ promise of free association, and demonstrates that this right includes the right not to belong to any specific organization. The author, Jonathan Wensveen, argues that compulsory student unions violate the individual rights of Canadian students, and that they should be replaced with voluntary student organizations. Wensveen examines the arguments that are presented in favour of compulsory student unions, and finds that none of them justify the abridgement of individual rights that occurs when individuals are forced to pay dues and belong to student organizations.

 

“The major arguments put forward for compulsory student unionism don’t stand up to scrutiny,” said Mr. Wensveen. “The reality is that the vast majority of the goods and services that student unions provide could easily be provided by voluntary organizations, which individual students could either belong to or not as suited their preferences.” Mr. Wensveen noted that it is morally problematic to compel individuals to belong to and pay dues to organizations whose views and actions they do not agree with. “Many student unions now spend a lot of their energy and money promoting ideologically charged advocacy campaigns that many students simply don’t support. To give just one example, student unions in Canada have funded protests against so-called ‘Israeli Apartheid.’ If individual students want to hold these protests, that’s their right, but there is no excuse for forcing students to fund political activities of this nature, when many of those students find the activities abhorrent.”  Mr. Wensveen argues that there is a straightforward solution to this problem, and that compulsory student unionism should be eliminated and replaced with a system of voluntary student organizations.

 

 

Download a copy of The Case for Voluntary Student Unionism HERE.

 

 

For more information and to arrange an interview with the study's author, media (only) should contact:

Jonathan Wensveen

jwensvee@gmail.com

Bookmark and Share


Related Items:



Author's Picture The Frontier Centre for Public Policy

is an independent public policy think tank whose mission is "to broaden the debate on our future through public policy research and education and to explore positive changes within our public institutions that support economic growth and opportunity."




Good Governance is Key with Chief David Crate - May 29, 2013


Upcoming Events

Good Governance is Key
with Chief David Crate
May 29, 2013 — Winnipeg

Dam-nation: Rolling the Dice on Manitoba’s Future
with Graham Lane
June 5, 2013 — Winnipeg


Yes

Upcoming FCPP Appearances

Community Policy Forum
Speaker: Steve Lafleur, FCPP Policy Analyst
Date: May 28, 2013
Time: 7:00 - 9:00 pm
Place: Grant Park McNally Robinson, Winnipeg, Mb


Thu May 23, 2013

Link to Prairie Weather


SymbolCurrent Price
Canadian $0.9702
US $1.0308
S&P/TSX12658.09
Dow Jones13147.18
NASDAQ3498.965
Oil94.65
Uranium40.75
Potash41.79