X Close

'25% is probably near the maximum tolerable proportion of taxation.'
Print
A A A

April 19, 2010

In Brief:

  • Winnipeg City Council is right to separate politics from long-term infrastructure planning
  • In France, 90% of similar private-public partnerships are renewed at contract renewal time


Media Release - Toward Greater Transparency in Water

It’s time to separate infrastructure from politics

The Frontier Centre for Public Policy today released a new report which examines the best practices on long-term management of civic infrastructure, such as sewer and water. Written by Calgary lawyer and water management expert Will Randall, the report, Toward Greater Transparency in Water and Sewer Services in Winnipeg, notes how the public-private partnership being considered by Winnipeg City Council on sewer services and infrastructure is an effective model.

“Imagine arriving home from a winter vacation to find a basement flooded with raw sewage, the reason for which was due to the long neglect by successive civic politicians who refused to properly fund public infrastructure,” comments Randall. “ That’s an unpleasant thought, but a possible scenario when such infrastructure ages without new investment in water and sewer systems. “

 

The report notes how the City of Winnipeg’s plan proposal to create a municipal corporation owned by the City to deliver water and waste services looks to be a model worth support. The proposed model would include a private partner to deliver waste services (not water) to Winnipeggers.

 

Report findings:

  • Such public-private partnerships are common around the world including in the examples highlighted in this study: Paris, France, Kingston, Ontario and Adelaide, Australia.
  • France turned to the private sector for water infrastructure, and satisfaction with water management is high in that country. Ninety per cent of cities that enter a public-private partnership continue the partnership at contract renewal time.
  • Adelaide, South Australia, retained government ownership of water and sewer infrastructure but contracted the operation of the system to a private firm, which resulted in cost savings.

Randall notes the benefits of a new water management model are increased transparency, long-term funding for needed infrastructure improvements in a non-political, nonpartisan manner, and cost-effectiveness and environmental protection based upon smart usage and smart planning.

 

The author also notes concerns over possible “gouging” are misplaced. “The Manitoba Public Utilities Board would regulate the proposed corporation’s rates in a more transparent process than does the current model. Such rates should encourage the environmentally sustainable use of water, and, overall, a move to such a system in Winnipeg would result in greater transparency, increased cost effectiveness and a more environmentally sustainable water system.”

 

 

Download a copy of Toward Greater Transparency in Water  and Sewer Services in Winnipeg here.

 

 

 

 

 

 

For more information and an interview, media (only) should contact:

Will Randall

Policy Analyst

403-466-9455
will_randall@hotmail.com

 

Mark Milke

Director of Research

403-230-2435

mmilke@fcpp.org

 

Bookmark and Share


Related Items:

 



Author's Picture Will Randall

is a consultant on efficient energy and water management for manufacturers, and he has worked for a landowner affairs’ organization. He holds degrees in law and industrial and systems engineering. He is a candidate for the Master of Laws in Energy, Environment and Natural Resources at the University of Calgary Faculty of Law.




Good Governance is Key with Chief David Crate - May 29, 2013


Upcoming Events

Good Governance is Key
with Chief David Crate
May 29, 2013 — Winnipeg

Dam-nation: Rolling the Dice on Manitoba’s Future
with Graham Lane
June 5, 2013 — Winnipeg



Upcoming FCPP Appearances

Community Policy Forum
Speaker: Steve Lafleur, FCPP Policy Analyst
Date: May 28, 2013
Time: 7:00 - 9:00 pm
Place: Grant Park McNally Robinson, Winnipeg, Mb


Fri May 24, 2013

Link to Prairie Weather


SymbolCurrent Price
Canadian $0.9681
US $1.033
S&P/TSX12658.09
Dow Jones13147.18
NASDAQ3498.965
Oil94.65
Uranium40.75
Potash41.79