X Close

Policy Series Paper 45 - Commissions of Human Wrongs - Click here

August 31, 2009 (FB079)


An ‘F’ for Social Promotion

by Michael Zwaagstra, M.Ed. and Dr. Rodney A. Clifton

Executive Summary

Social promotion is the practice of advancing students to the next grade even if they have not met the academic requirements of their current year. Generally, advocates of social promotion focus on the problems they associate with grade retention or repetition.

• The argument for social promotion rests primarily upon the claim that students kept behind end up worse off academically and emotionally than those socially promoted.

Despite the widespread use of social promotion in North American schools, there are good reasons to question this practice.

• Social promotion leads to graduates who lack the necessary knowledge and skills for academic success.

• Social promotion results in signifi cant ability disparities among students in individual classrooms.

• Many of the criticisms leveled at grade retention (i.e., higher dropout rates and damage to self-esteem) apply to social promotion.

• The negative effects of grade retention have been exaggerated.

• Social promotion has a negative effect on student motivation.

The practice of promoting students without suffi cient regard to academic ability or achievement needs to end. There are circumstances where students will benefi t from extra time in a particular grade or course.

View Entire Study (9 pages)

Bookmark and Share


Related Items:

  • Media Release

    Author's Picture Michael Zwaagstra

    has a B.Ed., a Post-Bachelor's Certificate in Education, and an M.Ed. in Educational Administration from the University of Manitoba. During his studies, he received numerous academic awards, including the Dr. A. W. Hogg Undergraduate Scholarship, the Klieforth Prize in American History, the Schoolmasters' Wives Association Scholarship, and the Aaron Bricker Memorial Scholarship. At present he is a high school social studies teacher in Manitoba. He has written a number of policy papers on Canadian education for the Frontier Centre for Public Policy in Winnipeg and the Atlantic Institute for Market Studies in Halifax. He is also a city councillor in Steinbach, Manitoba.



    Feedback:

    • RE: An ‘F’ for Social Promotion — September 15, 2009
      I couldn’t agree more! And thank you for publishing this important topic. These kids are not adequately prepared in public school for high school, and when they get there can’t even speak proper English, spell or multiply 9 x 7. Our Academic system in Canada is an embarrassment, as we are so far below the high standards set by so many other countries. I was about to call and make an appointment to have a meeting with the Principal of my grandson’s school on this very topic when I decided to look for any information I could find on the internet prior to meeting with her and this just substantiates what I’ve been telling them for the past 3 years. -- E-mail from Ontario
    • RE: An ‘F’ for Social Promotion — September 14, 2009
      The flip side of social promotion and "putting in your time" is what it does to gifted children. I know of a child who was doing introductory calculus as he finished first grade. The school staff insisted he do second grade the next year with the same students and the same dumbed down curriculum. The attitude of the school was "we will catch up with him." They even blamed the parents for teaching him beyond their level. They wouldn't consider finding an environment where he could be challenged. They kept talking about socialization and insisted his intellectual development would take care of itself. We are throwing away both the top and bottom by forcing them to stay with their age peers. This is why the dropout rate is so high on both ends. -- E-mail from Washington

  • Help Support New Thinking

    Localize website by geography




     

     

    Democratization of the Capital Markets with S. Mark Francis, Business Consultant/ Stock Exchange Advisor - March 24, 2010


    Upcoming Events

    How Hot Will It Get?
    with Dennis T. Avery, Senior Fellow at the Hudson Institute and Co-Author
    March 18, 2010 — Calgary

    Democratization of the Capital Markets
    with S. Mark Francis, Business Consultant/ Stock Exchange Advisor
    March 24, 2010 — Winnipeg

    Free Agent Nations: The Rise of Independent Contractors over Employees
    with Ken Phillips, Co-Founder and Executive Director,Independent Contractors of Australia and Author of Independence and the Death of Employment (Connor Court)
    March 30, 2010 — Saskatoon

    Beyond the Indian Act: Restoring Aboriginal Property Rights
    with Dr. Tom Flanagan, Professor of Political Science, University of Calgary
    April 5, 2010 — Regina
    April 6, 2010 — Winnipeg

    Beyond the Indian Act: Restoring Aboriginal Property Rights
    with Dr. Tom Flanagan, Professor of Political Science, University of Calgary &, C.T. (Manny) Jules, Chief Commissioner, First Nations Tax Commission
    April 6, 2010 — Winnipeg



    Upcoming FCPP Appearances

    Transparency and Accountability in the Public Sector - Panel #3
    Speaker: Joseph Quesnel, Policy Analyst
    Date: March 20, 2010
    Time: 4:35 pm (approx.)
    Place: John Dutton Theatre - Calgary Public Library

    Hosted by the Macdonald-Cartier Society. For more details contact Immanuel Giulea at 514.577.2669 or immanuel@macdonaldcartier.com

    Organizational Structure & Design HPG
    Speaker: Peter Holle, President
    Date: March 25, 2010
    Time: 7 - 9:00 p.m.
    Place: University of Manitoba, Room E2-160 Engineering Building

    A discussion on creating high performance policy by maximizing transparency, neutrality and separation; distinguishing between private and public goods; and locating services at the most appropriate level of government. University grad school lecture, not open to public.

    Manitoba Policy Blueprint for the Future
    Speaker: Peter Holle, President
    Date: March 30, 2010
    Time: 8:45 a.m.
    Place: Winnipeg Realtors, 1240 Portage Avenue, Winnipeg

    Booming Saskatchewan is on the verge of matching Alberta's flat income tax. Beleaguered Ontario is pushing to trim transfer payments. Alberta is under pressure to slash public spending and reform healthcare. Sales tax harmonization is happening in most provinces. How can Manitoba avoid being left in the dust in these turbulent times? Frontier's Peter Holle maps out how western Canada's only "have not" province can pull itself out of the slow lane. For more details contact: Shaila Wise at 786-8854 or swise@winnipegrealtors.ca



    Wed March 10, 2010

    Link to Prairie Weather


    SymbolCurrent Price
    Canadian $0.9751
    US $1.0255
    S&P/TSX11961.06
    Dow Jones10567.33
    NASDAQ2358.95
    Crude Oil80.16
    Uranium65.00
    Potash118.25