X Close

Somebody needs to do what we do . . .
Print
A A A

(045)
September 20, 2006

School Choice and Special Education Students

Executive Summary

  • Currently in Manitoba, school divisions receive funding for special education students based upon the number of Level I, II, and III students they have enrolled.
  • Because school divisions control this money, parents have limited say over educational programming decisions for their children.
  • Bill 13 attempts to rectify this situation by providing for a formal appeal process for parents. Unfortunately, this will only serve to centralize decision-making authority and force parents to work within an increasingly bureaucratic system.
  • Several jurisdictions, particularly Florida and Utah, have implemented voucher programs for special education students.
  • The McKay Scholarship Program in Florida was established in 1999 and enables parents of special education students to receive vouchers equivalent in value to the cost of one year of schooling in a regular public school. Parents are then free to spend this voucher in a private or public school of their choice.
  • A survey of the over 9000 participating parents revealed a high satisfaction rate with this program. In addition, class sizes for special education students in this program were almost cut in half.
  • Utah recently passed similar legislation enabling parents of special education students to receive vouchers to spend at schools of their choice.
  • Manitoba should consider emulating these successful programs rather than proceeding along the bureaucratic path of Bill 13.

    • Complete Backgrounder in PDF

    Bookmark and Share

    Related Items:

  • Why the Public School System Exaggerates Student Disabilities
  • Bill 13 – Mainstreaming Mania
  • Modified Voucher Would Improve Public Education
  • A Conversation with Angus McBeath, Edmonton Public School Board
  • For more about education . . .

    Author's Picture Dennis Owens was the Frontier's Senior Policy Analyst (1997-2007). A descendant of homesteaders near Portage la Prairie, he graduated from the University of Winnipeg in 1970 with a Bachelor of Arts in English and Political Science. Over a 20-year career in the transportation business, he rose to the position of operations manager of a Winnipeg-based firm. Since then he has researched and written about Canadian public policy issues for a variety of organizations including the Manitoba Taxpayers Association and the Prairie Centre. His specialties at the Frontier Centre include municipal issues, public education, healthcare and aboriginal policy. His frequent exposure in electronic and print media has included a regular commentary on CBC radio and articles printed in the Wall Street Journal and the National Post


    		•

    Good Governance is Key with Chief David Crate - May 29, 2013

    Upcoming Events

    Good Governance is Key
    with Chief David Crate
    May 29, 2013 — Winnipeg

    Dam-nation: Rolling the Dice on Manitoba’s Future
    with Graham Lane
    June 5, 2013 — Winnipeg

    Somebody needs to do what we do . . .

    Upcoming FCPP Appearances

    Community Policy Forum
    Speaker: Steve Lafleur, FCPP Policy Analyst
    Date: May 28, 2013
    Time: 7:00 - 9:00 pm
    Place: Grant Park McNally Robinson, Winnipeg, Mb

    Sat May 25, 2013

    Link to Prairie Weather

    SymbolCurrent Price
    Canadian $0.9699
    US $1.031
    S&P/TSX12667.22
    Dow Jones13147.18
    NASDAQ3498.965
    Oil94.65
    Uranium40.75
    Potash41.18