X Close

Somebody needs to do what we do . . .
Find us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Frontier Centre iPhone now available.
Blogging on the Frontier Our RSS

Media Release - National Coalition on Federal Transfers Launched

An informal coalition of six not-for-profit and think tank organizations have agreed the issue of federal transfers to the provinces needs to be placed firmly on the national agenda. As the current equalization agreement is set to expire in 2014, the coalition is hoping to shed some light on the current equalization scheme as well as the entire transfer system. Educating the public on these types of issues is the main contribution of Canadian think tanks. Public knowledge and awareness helps to ensure future agreements are both fair and equitable to all provinces and Canadians. Each of these organizations is working on independent research ideas that policy makers can consider in dealing with the imbalances created by the current system.


Equalization and EI are Hurting the West

Equalization has always been controversial in western Canada. With the economic boom in Saskatchewan and the strength of Alberta's economy, the dynamics of the program have changed. Premier Brad Wall feels that equalization and employment insurance are working against the movement of workers to both provinces, where many skills are in short supply. (2 min)

Join us weekly across the prairies for our hard hitting policy commentary broadcast across the Goldenwest Radio Network - Click here for a list of 14 stations and broadcast times.

The present 10-year agreement on federal provincial equalization transfer payments will need to be renewed in 2014. A coalition of 6 different think tanks are calling for a significant debate in this country on why and how we work equalization the way we do.  Joined by Charles Cirtwill, president and CEO of the Atlantic Institute for Market Studies.  (~14 min)

~13 min 

May 16, 2012 — National Coalition on Federal Transfers (CJME)
Equalization has always been controversial in western Canada. With the economic boom in Saskatchewan and the strength of Alberta's economy, the dynamics of the program have changed. Premier Brad Wall feels that equalization and employment insurance are working against the movement of workers to both provinces, where many skills are in short supply. (2 min)

~2 min 

February 17, 2012 — Equalization and EI are Hurting the West
Bryan Schwartz, University of Manitoba Law Professor and author of the Frontier Centre monograph Revitalizing Manitoba  maps out the case for a new political party that can articulate innovative public policy and ultimately rescue the province from the 'have not' province purgatory it is presently trapped in.

~32 min 

November 10, 2011 — Manitoba Needs an Ideas Party
Taming deficits is not easy. However, we have done it before. In 1993, Canada faced a deficit problem at least as serious as the one we confront today.  But by fiscal year 1997, the federal government balanced the budget and then ran a surplus every year until 2008.

~2 min 

August 26, 2011 — A Budget Triumph From Canada’s Past
David Henderson was interviewed by Murray Langdon on Victoria's CFAX 980 about how Canada can combat a growing budget and we have been getting our spending under control since the early 90’s. (~19 mins)

~19 min 

August 25, 2011 — Controlling National Expenses (CFAX)
David Henderson is the author of Canada’s Budget Triumph for the Frontier Centre which was originally published by the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. Listen to his interview from August 10, 2011 during a recent visit to Winnipeg.

~18 min 

August 22, 2011 — Conversation on the Frontier with David Henderson
Federal transfer payments have trapped Manitoba in a cycle of dependency and under-performance. Over the past decade, Manitoba’s provincial government has received approximately $20 billion from Canada’s equalization program. Sadly, this massive infusion of cash into the coffers of Manitoba’s government have actually done more harm than good for the overall health of the provincial economy. Find out more on this week’s Frontier Centre Commentary.

~2 min 

August 19, 2011 — Canada’s Equalization Program isn’t Working Properly (MB)
Equalization is a federal government program that takes federal tax dollars and transfers them to provincial governments in less affluent provinces. The objective is to ensure that Canadians in all ten provinces have access to comparably high quality public services. But in several areas, the program is overshooting the mark. Equalization sends so much money to the major recipients, that these provinces are often able to provide services that are actually more generous and accessible than what is available to residents of the provinces footing the largest part of the bill.

~1 min 

August 19, 2011 — Canada’s Equalization Program isn’t Working Properly
Most Canadians support the goal of the federal equalization program, which is to provide grants to poorer provinces in order to “ensure all Canadians receive reasonably comparable levels of public services at reasonably comparable levels of taxation.” But federal transfer payments have trapped Manitoba in a cycle of dependency and under-performance. Find out why on this week’s Frontier Centre Commentary.

~2 min 

August 12, 2011 — Equalization Traps Economies in Dependency Cycle (MB)
Law Professor Bryan Schwartz delivers a wide-ranging talk on how transfers underlie the unhealthy politicization of Manitoba's economy and community.  Includes questions and answers, from his Lunch on the Frontier address in Winnipeg, March 17th, 2011.

~68 min 

March 20, 2011 — Revitalizing Manitoba: From Supplicant Society to Diversity and Dynamism (Schwartz)
The Interprovincial transfer system hurts the payers, hurts the recipients and reduces the prosperity of our country. The system is, quite simply, broken. From the Frontier Centre's weekly radio commentary that runs in 3 prairie provinces.

~1 min 

March 7, 2011 — Time to Reform Canada’s Broken System of Regional Subsidies
Director of Research Marco Navarro-Génie was interviewed on CBC Radio Canada regarding Frontier's new Policy Series Study on Stealth Equalization. (French)

~8 min 

November 30, 2010 — How Subsidies Weaken Economies (CBC Radio Canada - French)

Latest Publications

New Brunswick Needs Financial Reality and Leadership

— May 11, 2012

Rather than focus on old, discredited explanations for New Brunswick’s poor economic performance, leaders must acknowledge the role that excessive federal subsidies play in underperformance.



Media Release - National Coalition on Federal Transfers Launched (Une coalition nationale sur la formule des paiements de transfert voit le jour)

— May 9, 2012

An informal coalition of six not-for-profit and think tank organizations have agreed the issue of federal transfers to the provinces needs to be placed firmly on the national agenda.



Financial Reality is Needed in Maritime Canada

— April 3, 2012

I’d like to start my presentation with a warning. The warning is that I’m going to speak very frankly about difficult issues. I will be taking fundamental issue with the approach the federal government, P.E.I., Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Quebec and Manitoba have been taking in relation to the many subsidies the Government of Canada provides to regions.



Canadians Vote With Their Feet

— February 15, 2012

No man is an island. What is true of individuals is doubly true of societies. When even in authoritarian societies such as Iran and China, YouTube videos from Tunisia, Britain or Argentina can be viewed the instant they are posted, even the humble and the oppressed know what life is like elsewhere.



Wealth Shared Unfairly, Study says;

— January 27, 2012

Ottawa is suppressing key parts of a politically explosive federal report that reveals Ontario is being shortchanged by Canada's national wealth-sharing scheme.



Chongqing, Bangalore and Canada

— December 21, 2011

David MacKinnon discusses the benefits of rapid economic growth in developing countries like China and India, as well as the challenges facing Canada in an increasingly competitive global economic environment.




Recent Updates


View More Policy Notes

Policy Notes - A One Page Policy Discussion

2012-05-11 – New Brunswick Needs Financial Reality and Leadership

2011-12-21 – Chongqing, Bangalore and Canada

2011-09-25 – Making Manitoba a ‘Have’ Province

» View More Policy Notes

View More Frontier Backgrounders

Frontier Backgrounders - Short Analyses

2007-04-05 – North and South: The Tragedy of Equalization in Italy

2006-08-03 – Whitehall’s Last Colonies

2004-04-16 – The Tasmanian Devil is in Equalization’s Details

» View More Frontier Backgrounders

View More Perspectives

Perspectives - Thoughts from the Advisory Board...

2012-02-15 – Canadians Vote With Their Feet

2011-10-21 – What 18th-century Scotland and Saskatchewan Have In Common

2011-06-29 – New Regional Policies are Urgently Needed

» View More Perspectives

View More Policy Series

Policy Series - Longer Reports & Studies

2011-08-30 – Balancing Act: Gradually Reducing The Size and Cost of Manitoba’s Public Sector

2010-11-15 – Stealth Equalization

2010-04-07 – Punishing Productivity

» View More Policy Series

View More Conversations

Conversations - with Policy Innovators

2011-08-22 – David Henderson, Economist

2011-01-21 – Calvin Helin, Author 'The Economic Dependency Trap'

2010-11-30 – Danielle Smith, Leader, Wildrose Alliance Party

» View More Conversations

View More Special Reports and Publications

Special Reports and Publications

2011-02-24 – Dollars & Sense

2007-08-09 – Equalization: Deal or No Deal? Does it Matter?

2002-04-01 – Ideas Matter - Equalization - Welfare Trap?

» View More Special Reports and Publications

View More PowerPoint Slides from Events

PowerPoint Slides from Events

2006-10-07 – Calgary Congress Powerpoint - Killing with Kindness

2005-03-12 – How Big is Manitoba Government? - PowerPoint

2004-04-05 – Fixing Manitoba's Balanced Budget Law PowerPoint Slides

» View More PowerPoint Slides from Events

View More Worth a Look

Worth a Look - In our Virtual Library...

2012-03-12 – Quebec Students Need Lesson on Equalization

2012-02-24 – The Coming War of the ‘Have-Nots’

2012-02-10 – A Flawed Formula

» View More Worth a Look

View More Charticles

Charticles - A Graphical Look at Issues

2011-09-21 – Manitoba Real Spending Up 65%

2008-04-07 – Ontario and Public Sector Padding in Manitoba

2007-11-22 – Equalization Pays for Manitoba's Cheap Hydro

» View More Charticles

View More Frontier Centre in the Media

Frontier Centre in the Media

2012-01-27 – Wealth Shared Unfairly, Study says;

2011-05-04 – O Conservatives

2011-02-25 – Ontarians Get Raw Deal in Wealth-Sharing System, Study Says

» View More Frontier Centre in the Media

View More Frontier Media Appearances

Frontier Media Appearances

2011-08-25 – Controlling National Expenses (CFAX)

2010-11-30 – How Subsidies Weaken Economies (CBC Radio Canada - French)

2010-03-29 – Quebec's Deficit and Equalization Perks - Not Fair? (BNN-TV)

» View More Frontier Media Appearances

View More Frontier Radio Commentary

Frontier Radio Commentary

2012-02-17 – Equalization and EI are Hurting the West

2011-08-26 – A Budget Triumph From Canada’s Past

2011-08-19 – Canada’s Equalization Program isn’t Working Properly (MB)

» View More Frontier Radio Commentary

View More Frontier Audio (Speeches/Events)

Frontier Audio (Speeches/Events)

2011-11-10 – Manitoba Needs an Ideas Party

2011-08-22 – Conversation on the Frontier with David Henderson

2011-03-20 – Revitalizing Manitoba: From Supplicant Society to Diversity and Dynamism (Schwartz)

» View More Frontier Audio (Speeches/Events)

View More Frontier Recommended Audio

Frontier Recommended Audio

2012-05-16 – National Coalition on Federal Transfers (CJME)

2008-04-12 – MacKinnon vs Selinger on Manitoba federal transfer dependency (CBC radio)

» View More Frontier Recommended Audio

View More Frontier Channel - Video

Frontier Channel - Video

2011-01-20 – Calvin Helin on Economic Dependency

2008-04-13 – Opiate of the Messes (Schwartz)

2008-04-13 – Opiate of the Messes (Schwartz)

» View More Frontier Channel - Video

View More Frontier Recommended Video

Frontier Recommended Video

2010-12-05 – Lemonaid

2010-11-12 – 'Britain's Trillion Pound Horror Story'

2010-01-15 – Economics 101: Moral Hazard

» View More Frontier Recommended Video

Help Support New Thinking


Upcoming Events

More events coming soon. Please join us then as we explore the frontier of public policy.



Upcoming FCPP Appearances

7th International Conference on Climate Change
Speaker: Dr. Harrison Schmitt, Apollo 7 lunar module pilot Walter Cunningham, Harold Doiron, Thomas Wysmuller and Tom Harris
Date: May 21, 2012
Place: Hilton Chicago, 720 South Michigan Avenue, Chicago, IL

Two Apollo-era astronauts and two prominent former NASA scientists will speak at The Heartland Institute’s Seventh International Conference on Climate Change (ICCC-7), taking place in Chicago on May 21–23. The four men were among 49 signatories to a March 28 letter to NASA and the Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS) urging the agencies to cease their “unbridled advocacy” of anthropogenic global warming. »read more

A Decade of Nisga’a Self-Government: A Positive Impact, but no Silver Bullet
Speaker: Joseph Quesnel, Policy Analyst
Date: June 8, 2012
Time: 8:30 am
Place: University of Calgary (2500 University Drive NW, Calgary, Alberta), MH Cassio B


Wed May 16, 2012

Link to Prairie Weather


SymbolCurrent Price
Canadian $0.9885
US $1.0116
S&P/TSX11326.08
Dow Jones13147.18
NASDAQ2874.04