X Close

Comparing cities . . .

Media Release - Indigenous Leaders Should Consider Reserve Relocations

It is wrong to subject future generations of Native youth to conditions that will not change—isolation far from educational and career opportunities. Human decency necessitates different thinking. The tragedy is that some isolated communities do not have a future and indigenous leaders should consider convincing their members to abandon present sites in favour of better ones.

In The News — January 28, 2010
Fruitful Decade For Many In The World

It may not feel that way right now, but the last 10 years may go down in world history as a big success. In economic terms, at least, the decade was a remarkably good one for many people around the globe, says Tyler Cowen, an economics professor at George Mason University.

The raging economic growth rates of China and India are well known, though their rise is part of a broader trend in the economic development of poorer countries. Ideals of prosperity, freedom and the rule of law have probably never been more resonant globally than they've been over the last 10 years, even if practice often falls short. And for all of the anticapitalistic rhetoric that has emerged from the financial crisis, national leaders around the world are embracing the commercialization of their economies, says Cowen.

Putting aside the United States, which ranks third, the four most populous countries are China, India, Indonesia and Brazil, accounting for more than 40 percent of the world's people, and all four have made great strides, says Cowen:

o Indonesia had solid economic growth during the entire decade, mostly in the 5 percent to 6 percent annual range.

o Brazil also had a consistently good decade, with growth at times exceeding 5 percent a year.

o Elsewhere in South America, Colombia and Peru have made enormous progress and Chile is on the verge of becoming a "developed" country.

o To be sure, in Africa, there is still enormous misery; nonetheless, overall standards of living rose in a wide variety of countries there, with economic growth for the continent as a whole at more than 5 percent in most years.

One lesson from all of this is that steady economic growth is an underreported news story -- and to our own detriment, says Cowen:

o In a given year, an extra percentage point of economic growth may not seem to matter much.

o But, over time, the difference between annual growth of 1 percent and 2 percent determines whether you can double your standard of living every 35 years or every 70 years.

o At 5 percent annual economic growth, living standards double about every 14 years.

Source: Tyler Cowen, "Fruitful Decade for Many in the World,"
New York Times, January 2, 2010.

See More "In the News"


Equalization, Unequal Incentives

Many people defend equalization as providing roughly equal services across the provinces. Ironically however, equalization often overshoots the mark. Recipient provinces actually end up with better services than the provinces who pay into the system. The federal government should stop the growth in equalization payments. Ottawa should instead motivate provinces to implement better public policy and to invest in growth instead of rewarding mediocrity.

Join us weekly across the prairies for our hard hitting policy commentary broadcast across the Goldenwest Radio Network - Click here for a list of 13 stations and broadcast times.

Current equalization policy is undesirable because of the perverse incentives which subsidise bad policies in recipient provinces. From the Frontier Centre's weekly radio commentary that runs in 3 prairie provinces.

~2 min 

February 5, 2010 — Equalization, Unequal Incentives
Frontier Centre Researcher Fergus Hodgson was interviewed by Adam Stirling on CFAX AM 1070 in Victoria on January 6, 2010.  (~13 mins)

~13 min 

February 4, 2010 — Homes for the Homeless (CFAX)
Senior Policy Analyst David Seymour was interviewed on CHQR's breakfast show by Bruce Kenyon on January 28th, 2010. (~6 mins)

~5 min 

February 4, 2010 — Calgary's Housing Affordability (CHQR)
Prominent Winnipeg citizen William B. Parrish, Previously Chairman of Parrish & Heimbecker, Ltd discusses his life in the grain business at Breakfast on the Frontier in Winnipeg, January 13, 2010.

~64 min 

February 3, 2010 — My Life in the Grain Business - William B. Parrish
Local Government Senior Fellow Larry Mitchell discusses the New Zealand approach to Local Government with Dave Dixon on CFAX AM 1070 in Victoria. (~17 mins)

~17 min 

February 2, 2010 — A Kiwi Perspective on Local Government Legislation (CFAX)
AIMS Research Manager Bobby O'Keefe was interviewed on Richard Cloutier Reports regarding the findings of Behind the Classroom Door: A Guide to the High School Report Card which was co-released with Frontier Centre for Public Policy. (~27 mins)

~26 min 

February 2, 2010 — Manitoba's Failing Grade (CJOB)
Schools should first and foremost focus on providing students with a solid grounding in the academic basics. Only once this is done should computers be introduced into the classroom. From the Frontier Centre's weekly radio commentary that runs in 3 prairie provinces.

~2 min 

January 29, 2010 — Too Much Media Is The Message
Frontier Senior Research Fellow Wendell Cox was interviewed by Murray Langdon on CFAX 1070 AM in Victoria regarding the findings of the 6th Annual Demographia International Housing Affodability Survey Janaury 26th, 2010. (~22 mins)

~22 min 

January 27, 2010 — How Affordable is Our Housing? (CFAX)
Executive Director of Winnipeg's Road Safety Awareness Group Nancy Thomas was interviewed on John Gormley Live on Saskatchewan's NewsTalk Radio January 25th, 2010. (~14 mins)

~14 min 

January 26, 2010 — On the Offensive Against Automated Traffic Enforcement (Newstalk)
Policy Analyst Ben Eisen was interviewed on The Rutherford Show on Calgary's CHQR AM 770. January 25, 2010. (~19 mins)

~18 min 

January 25, 2010 — Facts on Daycare (CHQR)
Instead of spending billions on a universal system, finite resources should be directed where they will do the most good. That means a smart, targeted approach that helps those in need pay for childcare, rather than a blunt and inefficient universal subsidy. From the Frontier Centre's weekly radio commentary that runs in 3 prairie provinces.

~2 min 

January 22, 2010 — Targeted Childcare Policies Deliver More Bang for the Buck
Director of Research Mark Milke was interviewed by Mike Blanchard on CHQR AM 770 in Calgary January 18th, 2010. (~18 mins)

~18 min 

January 19, 2010 — Equalization is Bad for All Provinces (CHQR)

Latest Publications

Time To Debate The Viability Of Some Reserves

— February 9, 2010

First Nation leaders should consider relocating reserves to better locations in order to maximize economic and educational opportunities for the next generation: some reserves are simply not economically viable



Respecting the Seventh Generation:A voluntary plan for relocating non-viable Native reserves

— February 8, 2010

First Nation leaders should consider relocating reserves to better locations in order to maximize economic and educational opportunities for the next generation: some reserves are simply not economically viable



Media Release - Indigenous Leaders Should Consider Reserve Relocations

— February 8, 2010

Non-viable reserves need to be identified by indigenous leaders –and moved, for the sake of the younger generation.



Manitoba’s Closed-Door Approach To School Information

— February 8, 2010

If we want our kids to be better educated and better equipped to take on the world, openness matters—a lot.



Wilfrid Laurier’s Values and a More Powerful West

— February 8, 2010

A strong Alberta leads to a more powerful West—which will be positive for all of Canada.



Climategate Necessary to Cover Incorrect Climate Basics of IPCC

— February 7, 2010

"Corruption disclosed was necessary because the science and the evidence didn’t fit what they wanted. They made the science fit the political goals and stopped at nothing to achieve the end. They succeeded, because beyond manipulations that duped politicians, media and most of the public, they knew many scientists who participated did not understand climate science."




Recent Updates


View More Policy Notes

Policy Notes - A One Page Policy Discussion

2010-02-09 – Time To Debate The Viability Of Some Reserves

2010-02-08 – Manitoba’s Closed-Door Approach To School Information

2010-02-08 – Wilfrid Laurier’s Values and a More Powerful West

» View More Policy Notes

View More Frontier Backgrounders

Frontier Backgrounders - Short Analyses

2009-10-22 – The End is Nigh

2009-09-24 – Manitoba’s Public Sector is Larger, More Expensive Than Most

2009-08-31 – An ‘F’ for Social Promotion

» View More Frontier Backgrounders

View More Perspectives

Perspectives - Thoughts from the Advisory Board...

2010-01-08 – Climate conference organizers asked for trouble in Copenhagen

2009-12-31 – Climate Skeptic: We are Winning the Science Battle

2009-12-20 – North Hides Nefarious Aims Under Green Cloak

» View More Perspectives

View More Policy Series

Policy Series - Longer Reports & Studies

2010-02-08 – Respecting the Seventh Generation:A voluntary plan for relocating non-viable Native reserves

2010-01-27 – Creating Proper Incentives for Canada’s Cities Through Smart Provincial Legislation

2010-01-18 – Myths about Childcare Subsidies

» View More Policy Series

View More Conversations

Conversations - with Policy Innovators

2009-11-13 – Brian Lee Crowley, Founding President of AIMS, the Atlantic Institute for Market Studies

2009-07-31 – Dr. Madhav Khandekar, Retired Environment Canada Scientist

2009-07-08 – Dr. Kenneth P. Green, Environmental Scientist

» View More Conversations

View More Special Reports and Publications

Special Reports and Publications

2010-02-01 – Behind The Classroom Door

2010-01-25 – 6th Annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey

2010-01-03 – Scientific American’s Climate Lies

» View More Special Reports and Publications

View More Rural Renaissance Notes

Rural Renaissance Notes

2009-09-02 – How U.S. Protectionism is Killing Canada’s Livestock Producers

2009-02-26 – Food Safety: Quality Matters, Not Just Price

2009-02-17 – President Obama Is COOLing It

» View More Rural Renaissance Notes

View More PowerPoint Slides from Events

PowerPoint Slides from Events

2009-12-14 – Measuring up Red Deer: 2009 Local Government Performance Index

2009-12-03 – Removal of nitrate-nitrogen from City wastewater will cost millions and achieve little

2009-11-30 – A Canadian Autobahn

» View More PowerPoint Slides from Events

View More Aboriginal Voices from Ground Zero

Aboriginal Voices from Ground Zero

2010-01-26 – Wanted: A New Vision for First Nations

2009-12-03 – Band Constitutions: A Tool For Accountability?

2009-11-06 – How First Nation Men Discriminate Against Women

» View More Aboriginal Voices from Ground Zero

View More Worth a Look

Worth a Look - In our Virtual Library...

2010-02-07 – Wheels Fall Off Global Warming Hysteria

2010-02-04 – Global Warming: The Collapse Of A Grand Narrative

2010-01-30 – Winds Of Change

» View More Worth a Look

View More Modern Environmentalist

Modern Environmentalist

2010-02-07 – Climategate Necessary to Cover Incorrect Climate Basics of IPCC

2010-01-23 – Climate Cools But Arctic Ice Scares Continue

2010-01-17 – Climate Misinformation and Contradictions Continue

» View More Modern Environmentalist

View More Charticles

Charticles - A Graphical Look at Issues

2010-02-05 – Canada v. Europe on Health Care: Europe Wins

2010-01-29 – More Money Doesn’t Always Equal Better Health Care

2009-12-03 – $44 per Day: An Early Christmas for Winnipeg Taxi License Holders

» View More Charticles

View More Frontier Centre in the Media

Frontier Centre in the Media

2010-02-07 – Speaker Bashes Regional Subsidies

2010-02-03 – Schools Need to be Graded

2010-02-03 – Province Refuses to Rank Schools

» View More Frontier Centre in the Media

View More Interactive Policy

Interactive Policy

2009-03-14 – The Frontier Goods & Services Interactive InfoMap

2008-09-15 – Saskatchewan Carbon Capture Opportunity Cost Calculator

2008-09-11 – Alberta Carbon Capture Opportunity Cost Calculator

» View More Interactive Policy

View More Frontier Media Appearances

Frontier Media Appearances

2010-02-04 – Homes for the Homeless (CFAX)

2010-02-04 – Calgary's Housing Affordability (CHQR)

2010-02-02 – A Kiwi Perspective on Local Government Legislation (CFAX)

» View More Frontier Media Appearances

View More Frontier Radio Commentary

Frontier Radio Commentary

2010-02-05 – Equalization, Unequal Incentives

2010-01-29 – Too Much Media Is The Message

2010-01-22 – Targeted Childcare Policies Deliver More Bang for the Buck

» View More Frontier Radio Commentary

View More Frontier Audio (Speeches/Events)

Frontier Audio (Speeches/Events)

2010-02-03 – My Life in the Grain Business - William B. Parrish

2009-12-24 – Why Competition Between Unions is Good (Brad Brent)

2009-12-14 – The Sky is Not Falling (Bruno Wiskel)

» View More Frontier Audio (Speeches/Events)

View More Frontier Channel - Video

Frontier Channel - Video

2009-12-18 – Healthcare Consumer Index Coverage (CBC SK)

2009-12-18 – Frontier Event Picketed (CTV Regina)

2009-12-11 – Explaining the 2009 Local Government Performance Index (Seymour)

» View More Frontier Channel - Video

View More Frontier Recommended Video

Frontier Recommended Video

2010-02-09 – Michael Coren with Dr. Tim Ball - part 1

2010-02-01 – Stimulus II: A Sequel America Can't Afford

2010-01-27 – Housing Affordabilty Survey (CTV National)

» View More Frontier Recommended Video

Feedback @ Frontier
RE: Why You Pay a Fortune for Airline Tickets — January 12, 2010

I was extremely impressed with your article about the lack of competition among North American air carriers. I fly within Europe fairly frequently and I am endlessly astonished by their low "domestic" prices in comparison with ours. Keep making noise Mark Milke! You hit the nail on the head. Who knows? Maybe one day the  Canadian  governments will wake up its slumber and truly support the competitive spirit it purportedly supports! Good for you! -- Email from Eric Scott, Montreal

RE: The Other Name For “Profiling”: Smart Detective Work — January 12, 2010

I think your article on profiling was very good.  As you said - it's just good police work. The example of people destroying their passport while enroute is easily solved - why don't we have the willpower to do it. --Email from Bob Spinney

RE: Climategate: Who’s In Denial Now? — January 4, 2010

Regarding Ken Green’s article, "Who's in denial now", which appeared in the Dec 28 Calgary Herald, I congratulate, and thank, him for a very well written, thoughtful, and truthful comment on climategate and the reprehensible agenda of the global warming frauds. -- E-mail from Calgary

RE: Shrink Waiting Lists the British Way — August 14, 2005
With reference to the UK medical system, there is a real crisis at the moment, the same one as here - most of our promising medical students, and theirs, want to specialize and thus progress into Residency. This results in a lack of GPs and how sad it is that a GP is almost looked upon as being "bottom of the pile," these days, prestige wise.Really sad to say, but very few patients have a GP who actually "knows them" and how they tick. At walk in clinics you are liable to get a different doctor each time. The other problem is, and this is the one the UK faces, there is not enough room in the hospitals for all the Specialists. They cannot get "hospital time," as it is called. Many doctors in the UK are facing unemployment and having to go to other countries to practice. I don't know but perhaps we have the same situation, here. - E mail from Robert Kirkpatrick, Winnipeg
RE: Aboriginal Governance Index — July 6, 2006
You and your colleagues are to be congratulated for the historic and heroic measurement of Band performance. My experience has been that the things that are measured get managed and your study, in my opinion, will be looked back at as the key turning point in the process of solving the problem of how first nations institutions fail first nations people. - Email from Michael Walker, Senior Fellow, Fraser Institute
RE: Floodway: Part of War on Mosquitoes? — September 26, 2002
I'm currently doing some work in Singapore and asked a resident why there were no mosquitos. The climate seems perfect for them. Apparently if you are caught with standing water in your property you are heavily fined and must pay for spraying yourself. The floodway modifications seem like a good idea but all the fountains and junk in peoples backyards likely are a huge factor that would be difficult and expensive for the city to address unless it hit people in the pocketbook. - email from Winnipeg resident in Singapore
RE: A Home Run for Winnipeg? — October 15, 2003
Very impressive. I was quite pleased to see you address the New Deal - I'm very interested in seeing where it leads. I'd still make my way back to WPG if its economic health were stronger. I am particularly interested in your points on capital costs (and how public corps are not reflecting through their prices the true costs of capital) - this is a very important area that you are addressing. Good to see!. E-mail from Ottawa (October 20, 2003)
RE: Eat Beef to Help the Environment — February 21, 2008
Cattle ranching is spreading like a virus across the planet, gobbling up our precious, ecologically diverse and carbon dioxide absorbing forests. It is no exaggeration to say that the expansion of ranching is a crisis that must be stopped, if life on Earth as we know it is to continue. Richard Brunt, Victoria
RE: Five Ways To Help Save The Earth--And Money — April 2, 2009
Mark Milke certainly pointed out more constructive ways to save the planet than the symbolic gestures of events such as Earth Hour. The disappointment expressed by the EcoLiving Events executive director, Judi Vandenbrink, that "there are a lot of naysayers out there" who don't understand the symbolism, leads me to believe a lot of us are not willing to be brainwashed by hypocrites like Al Gore and the rest of the climate-change zealots. The other day, I celebrated my 53rd birthday in near-identical blizzard conditions as the day I was born. Apparently, the winter conditions in 1956 had not been seen since the early 1900s. Gee, could this be a 60-year weather cycle? Cut the symbolism. Adopt Milke's five tips and really make an immediate difference. -- E-mail from Calgary
Frontier Flashback
2009 Local Government Performance Index
Some cities present glossy accounts of their performance with numerical measures while others can’t bring themselves to present adequate financial statements. If every city in Canada performed as well as the best cities, the entire country would be dramatically better off.
Ideas for Rural Voters
In some cases, this means that government should set the stage for economic growth and then just get out of the way. Two examples, oats and hogs, come to mind. In both cases, governments removed marketing impediments, and those actions resulted in the creation of improved opportunities for value-added agricultural processing. Investment and jobs followed.
Reforming Wheat Board Elections
A more rational way of weighting votes would be along the lines of economic interests. This would bring CWB governance in line with the more common business and Australian wheat board models, those with more “shares” or economic interest in the company have more at stake and therefore get more votes.
Selfish is Asking High-cost Provinces to Subsidize Low-cost Provinces
The inter-regional rip-offs that some defend on the grounds of a national concern only exacerbate regional tensions; they do not ameliorate them.
Aboriginal Women and Basic Human Rights
In another recent high-profile case in Manitoba, a woman from the Pequis First Nation was raped over a 26-year period before reporting the incidents to police. She had been treated so badly for so long, she was finally contemplating suicide. Sadly, more than 400 band members from Pequis, most of them women, wrote letters of support for the man accused of these crimes.
Alligator Eats A Crow
If you must compare me to a reptile can I be a crocodile? They’re bigger and meaner.
The Cause of Global Warming
Three of the four methods of measuring global temperature show no signs of global warming: * Proxy measurements (tree rings, sediments etc) for the past 1000 years * Weather balloons (radiosondes) for the past 44 years * Satellites (MSU Units) for the past 21 years. The fourth method, surface measurement at weather stations, gives an averaged mean global rise of a mere 0.6°C over 140 years, but is intermittent and irregular. Individual records are highly variable, regional, and sometimes, particularly in remote areas, show no change, or even a fall in temperature.
Climate Experts Respond to Arctic Climate Impact Assessment
hose examples demonstrate that Arctic climate has and will continue to exhibit intricate patterns not reliably reproduced by global climate simulations, thus underscoring their scientific incompleteness and need for advances in Arctic climate science, in measurements, theory and models.
Bring on Canada’s Autobahn
For many trips between Canadian metropolitan areas, it takes less time to travel through the United States on its motorways than on the Canadian roads. There is also a long section of roadway in the British Columbia interior that a Calgary talk show host referred to as a “stagecoach” trail. Canada pays an economic price for this lack of a world-class highway system, both in terms of manufacturing and tourism.

Help Support New Thinking

Localize website by geography




 

 

The Sky Is Not Falling – Putting Climate Change on Trial with Bruno Wiskel, Professional Geologist, Author and Speaker - February 12, 2010


Upcoming Events

Wastewater Problems in Cottage Country
with John Ilg, Process Engineer, FWS Industrial Projects Ltd.
February 10, 2010 — Winnipeg

The Sky Is Not Falling – Putting Climate Change on Trial
with Bruno Wiskel, Professional Geologist, Author and Speaker
February 12, 2010 — Calgary



Upcoming FCPP Appearances

State of First Nations
Speaker: Don Sandberg, Director of the Aboriginal Frontiers Project
Date: February 13, 2010
Time: Go to: www.ctstv.com for local viewing time in Calgary, Edmonton and Ontario
Place: Faith Journal Show - CTSTV

Studio interview with Don Sandberg, Frontier Centre for Public Policy, and Laura Deedza airing February 13 - 14, 2010.

What New Zealand can learn from Local Government Amalgamation in Canada
Speaker: Peter Holle, President
Date: February 17, 2010
Time: 6:00 pm
Place: Buddle Findlay Law Office, State Insurance Tower, 1 Willis Street, Wellington, New Zealand

At various times in Canada there have been moves to consolidate and amalgamate cities in different regions of the country. The reasons given in support of these policies have centred mostly around achieving greater efficiencies from larger economies of scale. But the experience has mostly been negative to mixed. Costs have increased while democratic accountability has decreased. As suggested by the Tiebout Model from the school of public choice economics larger city units have harmed the citizen customer of public services by removing their ability to vote with their feet when choosing the basket of municipal services offered by their local governments. Peter Holle, the founding President of the Frontier Centre for Public Policy, a Western Canada based public policy think tank, will review the Canadian experience and discuss the practical realities of amalgamation in Canada in this seminar at the Law & Economics Association of New Zealand (LEANZ). For more details contact: Matt Burgess at matt02@gmail.com

Telecommuting: Being There Without Being There
Speaker: David Seymour, Senior Policy Analyst and Director, Saskatchewan Office
Date: March 3, 2010
Time: 10:30 a.m. - 11:30 a.m. (approx.)
Place: Delta Bessborough, 601 Spadina Cres, Saskatoon, SK

Sustainable Saskatchewan Conference Telecommuting is a stealthy alternative to the more conventional transportation solutions which governments often promote. For more details e-mail: alicia.curle@seda.sk.ca

High Performing First Nations - Measuring Community Health and Governance
Speaker: Don Sandberg, Director of Aboriginal Frontiers Project
Date: March 4, 2010
Time: TBD
Place: Westin Hotel, 11 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, ON

AFOA 10th Anniversary National Conference The Frontier Centre for Public Policy released its third annual Aboriginal Governance Index (AGI) in the summer of 2009. The AGI is a result of surveys conducted in 98 First Nations across the Prairies with over 5,100 on reserve residents. The Index found that three measurements are the best indicators of the overall health of a band: 1) A trustworthy election process; 2) Transparent government and institutions and 3) Competent band administration. The O’Chiese First Nation in Alberta took the top spot on the Index. At this session there will be a discussion of the measurement/indicators that resulted, common indicators among the top ten reserves and what set those communities apart and contributed to their high ranking. Contact Micheline Belanger for more info Phone: 819.827.5031, Toll Free: 866.775.1817 or Email:

Manitoba Policy Blueprint for the Future
Speaker: Peter Holle, President
Date: March 18, 2010
Time: 8:45 a.m.
Place: Winnipeg Realtors, 1240 Portage Avenue, Winnipeg

Booming Saskatchewan is on the verge of matching Alberta's flat income tax. Beleaguered Ontario is pushing to trim transfer payments. Alberta is under pressure to slash public spending and reform healthcare. Sales tax harmonization is happening in most provinces. How can Manitoba avoid being left in the dust in these turbulent times? Frontier's Peter Holle maps out how western Canada's only "have not" province can pull itself out of the slow lane. For more details contact: Shaila Wise at 786-8854 or swise@winnipegrealtors.ca

Transparency and Accountability in the Public Sector - Panel #3
Speaker: Joseph Quesnel, Policy Analyst
Date: March 20, 2010
Time: 4:35 pm (approx.)
Place: John Dutton Theatre - Calgary Public Library

Hosted by the Macdonald-Cartier Society. For more details contact Immanuel Giulea at 514.577.2669 or immanuel@macdonaldcartier.com



Tue February 9, 2010

Link to Prairie Weather


SymbolCurrent Price
Canadian $0.9369
US $1.0674
S&P/TSX11115.30
Dow Jones9908.39
NASDAQ2126.05
Crude Oil72.79
Wheat1.94
Uranium65.00
Potash101.51